Marble It Up! (@MarbleItUp) August 27, 2018
@MarbleItUp has gone public. We will be launching soon on Switch. I wanted to talk a little bit about the game and how it came to be… and share some sweet GIFs (in high framerate black and white for download size reasons).
Just over a year ago, Mark Frohnmayer came to me with a proposal – let’s build a sweet marble game and put it on Switch. The Switch at that time was a brand new platform, but the potential was immediately obvious to both of us. I agreed to partner with Mark and all of a sudden – after several years away – I was back in the game development world.
I didn’t know it on day one, but making Marble It Up! was going to be a rare privilege. I am incredibly proud of this game – the team, the levels, the visuals and the gameplay are all amazing, and I count myself privileged to be involved. This is really a great game.
As we near release, I feel confident it will be a hit. I am just hoping it will be blockbuster Michael Bay hit, not a indie niche Kevin Smith hit. Anyway, on with the story…
Like Danny Ocean, we had to get the old crew together. I already had Miha, an awesome coder, on my team from past projects, so he and I got rolling (hah) right away. Meanwhile, we immediately reached out to Alex, original level designer for Marble Blast, and Todd, one of the most talented (and hardest working) artists I know. We also pulled in the incredible Solovox to make an awesome soundtrack and Mike Jones to do the rest of the audio.
Along the way we ran into long time fans of our work on the original Marble Blast series. We brought in the team behind QuiVR, Jonathan and Fletcher, as well as long time community members, speed runners and developers Matan and Conor.
With the team thus completed, we went into full production. Development slowed down a little bit when a few months into development my Loom technology was acquired and I had to devote my focus to a roll (ho ho ho) with the acquiring company. This ended up being short lived and I was able to refocus my attention after about 10 months of distraction (so to speak).
All of our development was self funded. This gave us total control over direction, but also required all of us to really commit to the game. We’re using a studio model for the game itself – it has its own entity that holds the IP and pays out royalties. Maybe I’ll talk about the basic structure we used for that some day down the road.
For this project, we used Unity 2017. It comes free with Switch developer access, and it looked like the best path forward on short notice. I briefly considered using Torque, the first commercial game engine I worked on. Because it was long in the tooth, it would require a solid porting effort before development could begin in earnest. We just didn’t have that luxury.
Although older versions of Unity were shaky, it has really matured in recent years and 2017 was easy to work with. Very quickly we had something up, and I started taking little progress GIFs (in black and white so they’d show up in Slack quickly). We got a ball rolling around in very short order:
The movement took a while to get right (more on that later). But ProBuilder made it super easy to throw a level together, and with a little work we got elevators going.
Being able to easily tie any geometry into a mover was a huge benefit for level design. It did require some discipline with prefabs to create consistent reusable elevators, but one-off showpieces like those found in Cog Valley or Staying Alive were super easy to make.
The physics simulation was very detailed, and one of the elements needed for both physics networking was a capacity for rewind. Instead of only allowing for a tick or two of rewind, I generalized to allow for arbitrary rewind. This made level testing MUCH easier:
And it also set the stage for two other features, ghost racing and replay. (I love ghost races way more than anyone else on the team, but I’m the lead programmer so they had to ship it.) Being able to watch and race against other players routes, as well as compete against yourself, adds loads of replay value to the game.
Not to say everything was wine and roses. We quickly found that Unity’s physics were completely inadequate for our needs. In the end, about half of the game code was for our custom marble physics engine. I feel comfortable claiming that no other marble game comes close to our level of fidelity. Part of the reason we have our own physics is in order to make them unrealistic, too – sometimes bending the laws of physics in juuust the right way makes things way more fun.
We also found that the default Unity renderer was really not appropriate for the game. Shadows provide important depth cues, but Unity’s dynamic shadows were fuzzy and required very careful level design and lighting to be present in all gameplay situations. In the end, a simple projected blob shadow gave us a crisp look and perfect visibility to support the gameplay. It also saved us many man hours tuning levels.
Particles were also a huge pain – especially mesh particles. Unity does horrible slow things to these and cost us massive amounts of performance on the CPU-light Switch hardware. In the end, we had to make small systems to handle the costliest cases in order to meet our performance goal of 60hz in handheld mode.
We also provide a full reflection on the marble. When I implemented this for Marble Blast Ultra, it took me a week or so to modify the scene graph to re-render the level in all six directions. Performance took some care, but ultimately it ran fine using more-or-less the default engine code. This was on the Xbox 360, which has way less RAM, a slower GPU and weaker CPU. Under Unity, on the more powerful Switch, we ended up having to write our own custom CommandBuffer based renderer and our own set of lightweight shaders in order to hit 60hz. This was an unexpected surprise late in development.
In general, Unity was excellent for prototyping and able to be coaxed into viability for production.
Man, I am stoked to see this game go out into the market. It has been a year of my life, some great challenges, some great fun, and hopefully, a game that brings a little bit of joy into the world. Let’s marble it up!